Butler-Tarkington Neighborhood Guide for Homebuyers

Butler-Tarkington is a neighborhood where collegiate energy, historic homes, and a tight-knit community come together on Indy’s near north side. If you’re considering a move here, let’s take a walk through Butler-Tarkington’s best features—highlighting local events, favorite spots to eat and sip coffee, and the welcoming vibe that makes this area truly special. At the end, you’ll find up-to-date stats to help you picture life in Butler-Tarkington.

Classic Charm Meets Campus Life

Start your journey on our Butler-Tarkington neighborhood page to explore the area’s mix of historic Tudors, brick colonials, and charming bungalows. The presence of Butler University gives the neighborhood its energetic feel and brings a calendar full of arts, lectures, and athletic events—don’t miss a Bulldogs basketball game at Hinkle Fieldhouse.

Eat, Drink & Gather

Butler-Tarkington’s food scene is relaxed and locally loved. Enjoy breakfast or lunch at Cafe Patachou, a local institution across from the university. For a sweet treat, head to Tarkington Bakery. Coffee lovers flock to Hubbard & Cravens for expertly roasted beans and a cozy vibe. Craving pizza? Broadsheet Pizza is a neighborhood favorite.

Events & Community Spirit

Community is at the heart of Butler-Tarkington. The Butler-Tarkington Neighborhood Association organizes seasonal clean-ups, block parties, and holiday celebrations. Stroll through Holcomb Gardens for peaceful green space and seasonal blooms, or catch a performance at Butler Arts Center. The neighborhood’s walkability and access to the Central Canal Towpath make it easy to get outside and explore.

Living in Butler-Tarkington: By the Numbers

Butler-Tarkington offers a blend of history and convenience. The average home price ranges from $300,000 to $525,000, with homes typically spending 22 to 38 days on the market. With top schools, beautiful parks, and a strong sense of community, it’s a favorite for families, professionals, and anyone craving a vibrant, welcoming neighborhood.

Want to see more? Visit our Butler-Tarkington neighborhood page to browse current listings and learn more about life in this special community—or reach out to start your Butler-Tarkington adventure!